In 2013, the International Conference on Database Theory (ICDT) began awarding the ICDT test-of-time (ToT) award, with the goal of recognizing one paper, or a small number of papers, presented at ICDT from at least a decade earlier that have best met the "test of time". The ICDT ToT award for 2014 will be presented during the EDBT/ICDT 2014 Joint Conference, March 24-27, 2014 in Athens, Greece.
The ICDT 2014 ToT Award Committee consists of Ronald Fagin (chair), Michael Benedikt, and Wim Martens. The committee was charged with selecting a paper or a small number of papers from the ICDT 1986 - 1992 proceedings that has had the most impact in terms of research, methodology, conceptual contribution, or transfer to practice over the past decade. After careful consideration, we have decided to select the following paper as the award winner for 2014:
Naturally Embedded Query Languages,
by Val Breazu-Tannen (now Tannen), Peter Buneman, and Limsoon Wong
This seminal paper strongly contributed to the establishment of the complex-object data model and its accompanying query languages. The paper had a significant influence on many important query- and programming languages. For example, LINQ and its monadic semantics finds its roots in this work, as do many language proposals following the map-reduce paradigm. XQuery, one of the most important languages for querying XML, is strongly based on the Nested Relational Calculus, which was introduced in this paper.
The paper identifies structural recursion over collection types (which generalize sets, bags, and lists) as the single computational device to explain the semantics of iteration, aggregation, quantification, filtering, joins, transitive closure, nesting and unnesting, and thus the core building blocks of rich query and collection-oriented programming languages. It is remarkable that structural recursion and the associated notion of monad also serves as a syntactic guideline: comprehensions, in various forms, have been at the heart of collection-oriented languages to this day. The authors identify restrictions that render the general recursion scheme as expressive as previously-defined languages for nested data structures, including the nested algebra or complex objects algebra.
The paper has approximately 200 citations to this date and its journal version, called "Principles of Programming with Complex Objects and Collection Types", with additional author Shamim Naqvi, has another 260 citations. It continues to spur interconnection between the database and functional programming communities.
Further information about the ICDT Test of Time Award can be found at http://icdt.tu-dortmund.de/#mozTocId274038.
In 2014, Extended Database Technologies (EDBT http://www.edbt.org/) will begin to give a test-of-time (ToT) award, with the goal of recognizing one paper, or a small number of papers, presented at EDBT from at least a decade earlier that have best met the "test of time". The EDBT ToT award for 2014 will be presented during the EDBT/ICDT 2014 Joint Conference, March 24-27, 2014 in Athens, Greece (http://www.edbticdt2014.gr/).
The EDBT 2014 Test of Time Award committee was formed by Gustavo Alonso, Torsten Grust and Walid Aref, all members of the EDBT 2014 PC and chaired by Sihem Amer-Yahia, the EDBT 2014 PC chair. The committee was charged with selecting a paper or a small number of papers from the EDBT 2004 proceedings that has had the most impact in terms of research, methodology, conceptual contribution, or transfer to practice over the past decade. After careful consideration, the committee has decided to select the following paper as the EDBT ToT Award winner for 2014:
Charu C. Aggarwal, Philip S. Yu:
A Condensation Approach to Privacy Preserving Data Mining. EDBT 2004, 183-199.
The paper addresses the topic of privacy-preserving data mining and proposes a framework for anonymization in contrast to perturbation approaches that introduce noise. The approach advocated in this paper takes into consideration the correlated nature of multi-dimensional data and also that is not problem-specific, i.e., the framework is generic and many mining operations can be formulated and solved given the same framework.
The paper is seminal and covers a topic which has not lost relevance today. It constitutes a prime example of how far a simple idea (in this case condensation: reduce a group of records to a number of carefully selected statistical properties of that group) can carry a whole line of original research. Condensation comes with a naturally built-in "privacy dial" (namely the group size) and is practical (easily implemented, maintainable under updates). It established general techniques that have been taken up by many people in the area and outside the area. The results in this paper can be (and have been) generalized in many ways as they tackled a more general problem of grouping, aggregation, and sampling.
According to Google Scholar, the paper has been constantly cited in the period from 2005 until today (2013) with a remarkable peak in 2008 when privacy-preserving data mining and database security in general became research topics of core interest. Since 2009 until today, the number of citations has only gone up. Papers citing this paper are also highly cited, indicating the relevance of the contribution.
A number of follow-up papers by the same authors, quite clearly demonstrate that the proposed condensation approach has interesting aspects:
Also in 2008, the Springer book "Privacy-Preserving Data Mining", edited by Aggarwal and Yu, was published.
Work on condensation-based privacy in data mining also had an impact on industry and industrial practice. At least the following US patents (or patent applications) are based on the idea of condensation: